New Delhi: The Supreme Court has banned a Class 8 Social Science textbook published by NCERT. The decision has sparked debate on how schools discuss public institutions.
The court reviewed a chapter titled “The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society.” The chapter mentioned issues such as corruption, case delays, and a shortage of judges.
A three-judge bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant said the content could weaken public trust in the judiciary. The court ordered a complete ban on printing, distribution, and online sharing of the book.
Authorities were also asked to collect existing copies of the textbook.
NCERT later withdrew the book and expressed regret over the issue. The organisation said the chapter was included due to an “unintentional error of judgment.” It added that the content will be reviewed before any future publication.
Former Supreme Court judge Justice Abhay S. Oka also commented on the issue in a recent podcast. He said sensitive topics about institutions must be explained with proper context in school education.
Justice Oka added that students should learn balanced information about the judiciary. At the same time, textbooks should help maintain public confidence in constitutional institutions.
The court’s decision has started wider discussion among teachers, legal experts, and policymakers. Many are debating how topics like governance and accountability should be taught to young students.
The controversy highlights a larger question in India’s education system. Experts say school curricula must balance critical discussion and respect for democratic institutions.
Share this content: